Lawsuit Scenarios
Dog bites, backyard pools, teen drivers, boat wakes, defamatory Google reviews. What each scenario has cost Canadians, which policy responds — and where it stops.
36 pages
A Child Is Hurt While You're Babysitting: Liability in Canada
A child's injury claim in Canada can run from a few thousand dollars for stitches to six figures for lasting harm — and a minor's claim can arrive years later. Here's who's liable when you babysit, when your teen babysits, and which policy responds.
A Contractor Got Hurt at Your House: WSIB, WCB and the Clearance Letter
Hiring a company doesn't end your exposure — crews get subbed out, and in most provinces the person who hired an uncovered contractor can be pursued for unpaid workers-compensation premiums. A clearance letter, requested before work starts, is the fix.
A Guest Gets Hurt at Your House Party: Your Liability, Explained
A guest who falls down your basement stairs or through a deck railing can produce a claim of $100,000 to $1 million or more — and it usually arrives months later, driven by their insurer, not their choice. Here's which policy pays, and where it stops.
A Guest Is Injured in Your Hot Tub: What Happens Next
Hot tub claims are smaller than pool claims but far more frequent — most settle between $20,000 and $150,000, and the bad ones reach seven figures. Wet decks, alcohol, and health events are the pattern. Here's which policy pays, and where it stops.
A Multi-Vehicle Pileup: When One Policy Limit Meets Five Claims
Your liability limit doesn't multiply with the number of people you injure. Five claimants in a chain collision divide one $1 million limit — while a single catastrophic injury alone can be worth $18 million. Here's the math nobody runs until it's too late.
A Neighbour's Kid Gets Hurt on Your Trampoline: Who Pays?
Under Canadian occupiers' liability law, you can be responsible for a child hurt on your trampoline — even one you never invited. Serious injuries produce claims from $50,000 to several million dollars. Here's which policy pays, and where it stops.
A Sea-Doo Crash on the Okanagan: The $2 Million Afternoon
BC's Enhanced Care no-fault system stops at the shoreline — a Sea-Doo crash on Okanagan Lake is a full tort lawsuit, and a serious one can top $2 million. PWCs are almost never covered by home insurance. Here's the gap.
A Snowmobile Collision on the Trail: Liability in Canada
A serious snowmobile injury claim in Canada runs from $500,000 into the millions, and coroners' reviews link alcohol to roughly half of sled deaths. Off your own property, insurance is mandatory — and your home policy isn't it.
Backyard Pool Accidents: Liability That Can Reach Millions
A backyard pool is the highest-severity liability risk a Canadian homeowner can own. Diving injuries and near-drownings have produced claims of $5 million and more — against a standard $1 million home policy. Here's how the gap works.
Before You Install It: Playsets, Ziplines and Backyard Liability
Canada's playground safety standard, CSA Z614, explicitly excludes backyard equipment from its scope — meaning a home playset or zipline is built to no safety standard at all, and your entire duty of care runs on ordinary occupiers' liability law instead.
Can My Own Passengers Sue Me?
Yes — a passenger is treated as any other injured third party, including a spouse, sibling, or best friend. Your insurer stands between you and them, which is exactly the point. The harder problem is several injured passengers sharing one policy limit.
Condo and Strata Liability: Who Pays When Water Comes From Your Unit
Often you do. When water escapes your unit and damages others, the corporation's own insurance deductible — commonly tens of thousands in Ontario, sometimes six figures in BC — can be charged back to the unit of origin. Here's the mechanism, by province, and where it stops.
One Facebook Post, One Lawsuit: Social Media Defamation in Canada
Canadian courts have ordered ordinary people to pay five- and six-figure defamation awards over Facebook posts and shares. Your home insurance typically covers none of it. Here's how online defamation works — and the policy that responds.
Shared Driveways, Fences and Retaining Walls: Who's the Occupier?
A failing retaining wall or shared fence is usually treated as a repair bill nobody wants to split — but if it collapses and hurts someone, it's an injury claim, and more than one neighbour can be the 'occupier' who answers for it. Here's how that works.
Someone Slips on Your Icy Sidewalk: Are You Liable in Canada?
A fall on ice that fractures a senior's hip regularly produces claims of $100,000 to $500,000. Whether you're liable depends on whose ice it was — your walkway, or the city sidewalk your bylaw makes you shovel. Here's how it actually works.
Sued Over a Beer-League Hockey Hit: It Happens in Canada
An Ontario court ordered a rec-league player to pay roughly $700,000 for a blindside hit in a non-contact league. Here's when a hockey play becomes a lawsuit, why income loss drives the numbers, and which policy answers.
Sued Over a Google Review: Defamation Liability in Canada
Canadian courts regularly award five and six figures for online defamation, and a business can sue you over a one-star review. Your homeowner policy typically won't pay a cent of it — here's the coverage that does.
When a Friend Helps You Move and Gets Hurt
An unpaid friend hurt helping you move, build a deck, or take down a tree usually isn't a workers' compensation case — there's no employer, so no WSIB or WCB claim. It's a straightforward negligence claim against you personally, and your home policy is what actually answers it.
You Coach Kids' Soccer. A Parent Sues. Now What?
Volunteer coaches can be personally named in Canadian lawsuits. The sport organization's policy responds first — but its $2–5 million limit is shared across the whole program. Here's how the insurance layers stack, and where yours takes over.
You Doored a Cyclist: What It Costs and Who Pays
Opening a door into a cyclist is an offence under highway traffic legislation in most provinces — and the fault is presumptively yours. Serious injuries drive claims from six figures past $1 million, paid by your auto policy up to its limit.
You Hit a Pedestrian: What Happens to You Financially
In several Canadian provinces, a driver who hits a pedestrian is presumed negligent until they prove otherwise. Catastrophic pedestrian injuries produce claims in the millions — against auto policies that stop at $1 million or $2 million.
You Lent Your Car to Someone Who Shouldn't Have Been Driving
An ordinary lent-car crash still leaves your policy responding. A suspended, excluded, or undisclosed driver is different — Ontario's excluded-driver endorsement deems the vehicle uninsured entirely, one of the few genuine uninsured-exposure gaps in Canadian auto insurance.
You Lent Your Car. They Crashed It. You're on the Hook.
In most Canadian provinces, lending your car means lending your liability: the owner is legally responsible for a crash caused by anyone driving with consent, and your policy — and your record — respond first. Canadian awards have exceeded $12 million.
Your Airbnb Guest Gets Hurt: Who Actually Pays?
A guest's fall at your short-term rental can produce a claim past $100,000. Airbnb's AirCover offers up to $1M USD in host liability protection — but it isn't your insurance, and your home policy may exclude hosting entirely.
Your ATV Passenger Is Seriously Hurt: Who Pays?
A serious ATV injury claim in Canada regularly runs from $500,000 into the millions — and the passenger's lawsuit lands on the driver and the owner. Coverage changes the moment you leave your own property. Here's how.
Your Boat's Wake Flipped a Canoe: Liability on Canadian Water
In Canada you are legally responsible for your boat's wake, and a swamped canoe or injured swimmer can produce a claim of $500,000 or more. Auto insurance never covers it — here's what does, and where it stops.
Your Dog Bites Someone: What a Dog-Bite Lawsuit Costs in Canada
In Ontario, dog owners are automatically liable when their dog bites — no negligence required. Serious attacks on children have produced six- and seven-figure claims. Here's which policy pays, and where it stops.
Your Dog Ran Into the Road and Caused a Crash: Who Pays?
When a loose dog causes a cyclist or driver to crash, the dog's owner can be liable for the full injury claim — often several hundred thousand dollars — and it's usually your home policy, not an auto policy, that answers.
Your Dog Walker Was Injured. Can They Sue You?
Generally yes — a paid dog walker injured by your dog can sue under the same strict-liability rules that apply to any third party, and Canadian law hasn't settled whether their training changes the analysis. Your home policy's typical $1 million limit responds either way.
Your Drunk Guest Crashes on the Way Home: Are You Liable?
Canada's Supreme Court says social hosts who merely serve alcohol aren't liable when a drunk guest crashes — but the exceptions are real, and even a claim you win can cost $100,000 to defend. Here's which policy stands in front of you.
Your Firepit, BBQ or Hot Tub and the House Next Door
A backyard fire that spreads to a neighbour's house is a liability claim, not just bad luck — and in a row of semis or townhomes, one fire can draw claims from more than one direction. Here's which policy pays, and where it stops.
Your Golf Ball Hits Someone: Can You Be Sued in Canada?
Yes — Canadian golfers have been sued over errant shots. A serious eye or head injury can produce a claim from $100,000 to over $1 million, and it's your home insurance that answers it. Here's where bad luck ends and negligence begins.
Your Teen Causes a Serious Crash: Are Parents Liable in Canada?
In most Canadian provinces, the parent who owns the car is liable for a crash their teen causes — the largest reported award, against a 16-year-old driver, was about $18.4 million. Here's how owner liability works and what actually protects you.
Your Tenant Caused the Damage: Subrogation, Deductibles and Lost Rent
A tenant's overflowing tub or unattended stove can trigger a repair bill, a deductible nobody covers, months of lost rent, and — for the tenant — a subrogation letter demanding the money back. Here's how it plays out for both sides.
Your Tenant's Dog Bit Someone. Are You Named?
Often named, rarely found liable for the bite itself. Ontario's strict-liability rule targets whoever 'possesses or harbours' the dog — usually just the tenant — but a landlord who knew it was dangerous and did nothing can face a separate negligence claim.
Your Tree, Their House: Who Pays When a Tree Comes Down
Storm damage is usually nobody's fault — each side claims on their own insurance. That changes the moment there was prior notice the tree was rotten, cracked, or already dropping limbs. Here's where the line actually sits.
How exposed are you? Most people have no idea.
10 questions. 2 minutes. No email needed to see your score.
Check my lawsuit exposure